-24%
Original price was: $128.95.$97.99Current price is: $97.99.
- Safe Payments, Happy Customers
- Shop the Best Quality Online
- Risk-Free Shopping with Returns
- Protect Your Information, Shop with Safe Payments
- The McGuffey Casual Plain Toe Sneaker is anything but bland with its rich yet relaxed style.
- Water-resistant suede uppers with full grain leather accents.
- Lace-up closure for an adjustable fit.
- Skeletal leather lining for a soft and unconstructed feel.
- Cushioned textile, and leather-lined footbed.
- Durable and textured rubber outsole for added traction.
- Imported.
- Product measurements were taken using size 12, width M (D). Please note that measurements may vary by size.
- Weight of footwear is based on a single item, not a pair.
- Measurements:
- Weight: 1 lb 1 oz
| Color | Black Oiled Nubuck, Brown Oiled Full Grain, Gray Nubuck, Navy Nubuck |
|---|---|
| size | 10, 10.5, 11, 11.5, 12, 13, 14, 7, 7.5, 8, 8.5, 9, 9.5 |
| width | M (D), W (EE) |
25 reviews for Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Casual Plain Toe Sneaker | Sneakers & Athletic Shoes
Add a review
Related products
-42%
Original price was: $167.95.$97.99Current price is: $97.99.
-32%
Original price was: $119.99.$81.59Current price is: $81.59.
-37%
Original price was: $155.00.$96.99Current price is: $96.99.
-32%
Original price was: $138.95.$94.99Current price is: $94.99.
-32%
Original price was: $99.00.$67.32Current price is: $67.32.
-32%
Original price was: $65.00.$44.20Current price is: $44.20.
-46%
Original price was: $175.00.$94.99Current price is: $94.99.
-45%
Original price was: $175.00.$96.99Current price is: $96.99.
Raymond H –
As I noted in my comments regarding the blue suede version I also purchased, these are quite comfortable from the first time wearing them.
Anonymous –
I love these shoes! They are my new favorites! Very comfortable while being practical and they look nice also.
Anonymous –
Don’t buy if you use custom orthotics — the insole that comes with the shoe is sewn in and cannot be removed.
Anonymous –
I purchased the Gray Nubuck color. very versatile color! love the look of the shoe, however, the arch support is not in the correct spot for my feet. I wear size 10. the burnish on the tip is not even on both shoes and that just bugs me to look at it.. (just not necessary)… hopefully it will fade in time… the disappointing factor is that the padding on the inside is not easily removable. I wanted to just take it out and put in a support that I know works well.
I’ll have to wait to try this since it is a Christmas present to myself and I can go destroying it yet…lol . if anyone has any suggestions before then please let me know.
Jay –
They looked really nice and they are comfortable but not good for longer walks. They do not hold up very well, had them about 5 months and the the soles are about worn through on the back heel. The laces are terrible as well I had to replace those after 3 months. I work in an office so its not like I am out landscaping in them. For the $130 price tag I expected them to hold up much better than this. I have other JM shoes that I loved so I though this was a brand I could trust. I would not buy these again even if they were half the price.
Anonymous –
This shoe was great! I got them as a gift for my boyfriend who has wide feet. He loved them but they were a bit big so I plan to repurchase them in another size. I also got them as a gift for my dad last year and he is obsessed with them. If you have wide feet, these shoes are perfect!
Anonymous –
I fell in love with the shoes when I first received them. They’re super versatile with different clothing and accessories. However, after having the shoes for 6 months and wearing them less than probably 30 times, they’re starting to fall apart. The leather upper is separating from the sides near the area of the shoe where it bends via the fit. Definitely not worth the the price for the wear I’ve gotten out of them.
Chris –
These are some of the most (if not the most) comfortable casual shoes that I own. I purchased them because of the style and look but after I put them on for the first time I was blown away by how comfortable they are. I have worn them about a dozen different times now and they still are as comfortable as the first and are not showing any signs of unexpected wear. I have not worn any other models of Johnston & Murphy shoes but after the experience I have had with these, I will be giving their other models a shot too.
Tim –
Really liking these shoes so far. I’ve had foot problems for so long, and I’m realizing that I need wide shoes. The comfort is so much better, my feet are thanking me.
Elias O –
The shoe fits great and looks great. I am not too thrilled about the toe being a darker shade of grey, but I knew that was the case going in so I won’t knock off any points. Very comfortable shoes.
Daniel C –
Very comfortable for me as I am on my feet all day. They are dressy enough to wear to work.
Anonymous –
Johnston and Murphy shoes are very comfortable! I wear a size 7 M which is hard to find. As soon as I found these, I ordered them. Please let me know of other size 7s you may have. Thank you!
Derrick P –
Good fit very comfortable size 10 wide. I Can wear them all day. I wished the black weave slip on came in wide sizes
Stephen S –
Great fit and comfortable
Andy C –
I am a teacher and these shoes are amazing given that I’m on my feet all day.
Anonymous –
This is my second pair. They are true to size and a great casual look.
Anonymous –
Fit was perfect and very comfortable. What you would expect from Johnston & Murphy. Like the style. Sneakers look great for business casual.
Constantine –
Bought a pair off Facebook marketplace, and oh boy, they are comfy. I have flat wide feet and the shoes feel so mine. I rarely get such feeling. The leather is soft and elastic at the same time. I also like there is canvas inside just leather.
Anonymous –
Have worn these shoes for a few months now, primarily to work. Very comfortable, would buy again.
Anonymous –
I did return them but it had nothing to do with the shoes quality or anything like that. I have big toes that sort of point up at the end. So my toe nails rubbed the top of the shoe. Had the tie box been a fraction taller I’d have kept them.
Anonymous –
Very comfortable and well made. The leather and suede is soft but been very durable. They are a bit wider than I would expect, but not unpleasantly so.
Anonymous –
Hubby loves these. His feet have widened over time so these are a nice alternative to Ecco sneakers, which have been running super narrow in recent years.
Lee –
These shoes are awesome. I’ve been searching for a pair of dress shoes for a while and finally thought I’d try Zappos. The shipping is fast and easy return if you need to. Next time I’ll start with Zappos
Anonymous –
Shoes are true to size and the quality of Johnston and Murphy shoes feels and looks top notch. I have had 3 pairs of their shoes already and will keep coming back.
Anonymous –
Great purchase my boyfriend loves them and they look good with everything